Are You Still Watching? 👀

Are You Still Watching? 👀

On Mother Mary and the pleasures and pitfalls of pop star cinema 🎶

Plus, In The Mood's next events in Toronto and Montreal...

In The Mood Magazine's avatar
In The Mood Magazine
May 01, 2026
∙ Paid

You’re invited…

Event poster with info and lineup

🌀 In the Mood Magazine x Metatron Press present METAMOOD 🌀

Join us in Toronto for an afternoon for readings and collective discussion to celebrate the launch of Wavering Futures by Kawai Shen:

Sunday, May 17
It’s Ok* Studios (468 Queen St West, Toronto)
1:00-3:30pm

Get your tickets

Featuring readings by:
✽ Kawai Shen
✽ Sennah Yee
✽ Trynne Delaney
✽ Nirris Nagendrarajah
✽ Lee Suksi

🗓️ P.S. Save the date: We will be hosting part two of METAMOOD in Montreal, June 7th at Parquette!


Give Us Nothing

In The Mood’s editors on the pleasures and pitfalls of pop star cinema

by Gabrielle Marceau & Sennah Yee

Movie still from Mother Mary. Mary performs on stage, her own image on the screen behind her.

“Blood on White Satin” - Skye Riley

Sennah Yee: In Mother Mary, Mary’s only rule for her seamstress Sam is that her new dress can’t be red. The colour literally haunts and possesses them both: the ghost takes the form of a floating, silent tornado of red fabric, inspired and designed by artist Daniel Wurtzel.

Red has always been my favourite colour—it’s the colour of my favourite Robert Munsch book, of race cars, of lucky envelopes, of my wedding dress. I’ve had red streaks in my hair thanks to L’Oréal Colour Rays, a now-discontinued product specifically for dark hair that requires no bleach. My dad would help me apply it, and I would lay my head on a towel on the kitchen table with tin foil in my hair, my neck painfully twisted while I patiently waited to be transformed.

Mary and Sam dance around what her dress and this “comeback” show represents: a beginning, an ending, a secret third thing? Pop stars are in constant states of invention and reinvention, changing their outfits, their hair colour, their sound. Mary’s image apparently had many evolutions, though the film doesn’t do much to convince us of this—when they show off previous tour outfits, I couldn’t tell one era from the other. Perhaps the transformations were just in her head.

Gabrielle Marceau: Other than the red ghost, the palette of David Lowery’s Mother Mary is black and grey. The present action is set entirely in a repurposed barn in the British countryside, the ascetic headquarters for Sam’s fashion line, where she drinks bright blue tea and eats no food. Pop star cinema has gone grim; think of the wintery setting, dark glitter, and bleak outlook of Vox Lux; or the moody, low-light interiors and sado-masochism in The Idol; or Skye Riley’s black lacquered apartment in Smile 2 (not to mention the unrelenting darkness of the plot).

We know pop music has a dark side, we have seen its many casualties. But pop is dark because of its light facade: bright smiles, bright colours, bouncing, catching, sweet. Underneath: drain, depression, drugs and the pressure to continue performing. Pop star cinema makes this split literal: In a scene in Smile 2, the beleaguered pop icon is looking at herself in the mirror, when suddenly two fingers from a faceless body behind her are pulling her mouth into a smile.

When The Idol aired, images from the set of the show when Amy Steimetz was at the helm circulated online. Crew members posed with cardboard cutouts of Lily-Rose Depp wearing lime green and baby pink, in a bedroom set reminiscent of Britney Spears’ childhood bedroom, captured by David LaChapelle. They gave us a glimpse of her version of the pop star satire, one that seemed more grounded in reality, less self-consciously dark, and decidedly more female. It’s worth noting that all the visions of female pop stardom we talk about in this piece are directed by men.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of In The Mood Magazine.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 In The Mood Magazine · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture